Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Blog Reflection #4

This is a tough one. Print sources or electronic sources? I have a small English dictionary and a French-English dictionary with me all the time. When writing, I have a really, really old Roget's Thesaurus next to me. I often wonder if I should get a new one, but I don't usually need "newer" words. I mean, what can be synonymous with "wikiality"? And, anyway, my husband just tells me to use the one designed into the latest version of word!
In completing the assignments for this week I went to the library at CSULB and used the print references there. I do believe I was the first to open the latest edition of the "Encyclopedia of Associations" on their shelves, and it was so nice to hear the binding crack a bit and smell that new book smell. It's better than new car smell, I think! But, let's face it, the internet and electronic publishing are definitely becoming, if they have not already become, the best way to find, source and access information. In fact the librarians at CSULB thought the Encyclopedia of Associations was ONLY available on-line! As we have discussed many times in this class, the biggest and most difficult obstacle in using the internet as a reference source is ensuring that source is both reliable and verifiable. Education in this area is the key, and I have been thinking that this education has to start as soon as a child has to start learning facts. Not only do librarians and library employees need to help students learn how to use the internet's resources, teachers must be educated, too. Teachers will need to be able to verify the sources their students quote and cite on papers, and know those citations are legitimate. Perhaps starting out limiting student searches to reliable web-sites would be a beginning to their on-line eduction, but teaching them to determine the reliability of a source, ensuring that what they are using as a fact is truly a fact and double checking the veracity of that source must become a standard for all schools.
I think, if I were a librarian who needed to chose between print or electronic reference sources, I would have to go with the electronic source. I would try to stress the importance of reliability, conduct informational classes on the uses for these sources and, probably, keep an older, print version of the source, just in case...

2 comments:

Jennifer said...

That's a interesting point you've made about renewing editions with newer words/"wikiality". I hadn't thought of it that way before. I do love that old book smell though.

-Jennifer Gallegos
http://jengallbcc.blogspot.com/

Michele-library204 said...

I also looked up the Associations online - an electronic library database called Associations Unlimited